Monday, September 11, 2023

Stayin' alive

 KEEP YOUR BLOG ONLINE

Drawing of a man waking up in a coffin
Google's plan to start deleting inactive accounts (and their blogs) begins this December.

What does it mean to you, and how can you protect your blog?

The actual requirements are simple. Just publishing blog posts keeps the account active.

But there's a nasty surprise for some blogs.

The policy

1. Google's new policy is that it may delete inactive accounts after two years. Quote:
Google reserves the right to delete an inactive Google Account and its activity and data if you are inactive across Google for at least two years.
2. It may also delete some services (such as YouTube) from active accounts if the service has not been used for two years.
This is determined based on each product's inactivity policies.

At the present time, Blogger does not have its own activity requirement.

So, inactive blogs will be maintained as long as the account is active.

The rollout

Google has never deleted an account for inactivity before. It announced the new policy in May.

The announcement promises to proceed slowly, at least at first (emphasis added):

We are going to roll this out slowly and carefully, with plenty of notice:

• While the policy takes effect today, it will not immediately impact users with an inactive account—the earliest we will begin deleting accounts is December 2023.

• We will take a phased approach, starting with accounts that were created and never used again.

• Before deleting an account, we will send multiple notifications over the months leading up to deletion, to both the account email address and the recovery email (if one has been provided).

If your account contact information is not up to date, you won't get these warnings. 

The surprise

It's not obvious, but if there were ever other accounts on the blog, and those accounts are deleted for inactivity, any images they uploaded into the blog will be deleted too.

You can lose images that way.

The scenario might happen if you started your blog with a dedicated blogging account, but then transferred the blog to another account that you use for email and other services.

It could follow if you have or had a team blog with images uploaded by a co-author in his or her posts.

It applies even if the originating account is no longer linked to the blog.

Images cannot be transferred from one account to another in Blogger. Blogs can be transferred, but the images remain hosted in the originating account.

When a blogging account is deleted

It's worth reviewing what happens when an account that has a blog is deleted.
  • If the account is the sole account on the blog, as administrator, the blog will be deleted along with everything else in the account.
  • If there is another account on the blog that is not deleted, the blog will persist. If the deleted account was the sole administrator, ownership will pass to one or more non-admin authors, who will become administrators.
  • In that case, the blog posts from the deleted account will persist.
  • However, images uploaded from that account will be deleted.

My advice

Contacts: Google says they will try to contact you before deleting any of your accounts, at least initially.

So, make sure your account contact information is up to date. Typically, email and cell phone.

Google's efforts to reach you will only be as good as the information you provide.

You can revise contact information in the settings for your Google account, under personal info > contact info.

Old blogs: If your blog is inactive, but you want it to remain online, sign in to your account once a year and use it to perform a Google search, watch a YouTube video, or send an email (to anyone).

(The requirement is actually once every two years, but why risk forgetting?)

Update: Google also says it won't delete any accounts "for the time being" if they have uploaded a video to YouTube.

That sounds kind of sketchy, but it's something else you might do.

You might want to do this if your blog is of abiding interest to family members or others. Also, see "Legacy" below.

Hidden accounts: To avoid a nasty surprise, inventory all the accounts that ever wrote blog posts.

Gain access to all of them and make sure the contact information is up to date.

Activate them once a year, too. 

Or, if there are only a handful of images that would be deleted, edit the affected posts by replacing the images with the same ones uploaded from an active account.

If you do that, you can just forget about the originating account.

Update: I've published a guide to tracking down these hidden accounts.

Legacy: If you wish your blog to survive you, you'll have to arrange to have someone activate the account regularly. That person will need your account credentials.

I suggest asking them to do this once a year, on your birthday, to make it easy to remember.

Also, ask them to keep the account contact information up to date for them.

There can be a lot of issues when Google gets a sign-in request from a new location and device. So, to make sure this goes smoothly, I recommend

  • providing a set of one-time backup codes along with your account credentials
  • asking your digital heir to try signing in now, while you are still around to assist.

Be absolutely clear about this

This policy is a major departure for Google and introduces an element of time where it did not exist before. 

If you drop the ball you could lose part or all of your blog.

So, I suggest it is worth reading carefully

Today's image, via Open Clipart, is in the public domain.

27 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. In its May announcement, Google said the main reason had to do with spam and security.

      For what it's worth, that explanation makes sense to me.

      Delete
    2. I think it also has something to do with saving storage. Every single account (specially the ones that were used at some point) take a little bit of space from their servers. They never say something close to this in their announcement but it's just my thinking.

      Delete
    3. @Anony: We'll never know for sure, I guess. The question is how to protect our blogs!

      Delete
    4. Worth noting that over the past several years Google had been putting new storage policies in place even prior to this change.

      Delete
    5. June 2024 anony: That has always been true, but this is the first time (isn't it?) there has been an "activity" requirement.

      I'm skeptical of the notion that this is about cutting Google's costs, since storage has never been cheaper. But (a) who knows and (b) it doesn't matter in terms of what our options are.

      Delete
  2. Hey Adam! Question - is there any easy way to tell if any other account has made a post? I've had my blog since 2003 - a spot check shows all post by me, but I may have had a different account at some point that I don't remember.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Chris, you can search by author from your dashboard—if you remember the author name!

      If not, you have to check old posts. If the blog does not display the author name, you can add the authors in, then remove them after you've done your check if you like.

      If you suspect you started with a different account with an identical display name (tricky!), check that by clicking on the name to view the profile page. Each profile has a unique ID number in the url.

      Delete
  3. If a blog get deleted due to its inactive account, can its URL be used by someone else?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it can....a friend's site "Ripple in Stillwater" blog link now leads to someone else's page. All his links on his Facebook page to his blogs lead to this replacement page that isn't really anything- just a sort of storefront of a nonexistant journalist.

      Delete
    2. @Linda,

      Sorry about your friend's blog, but I stand by what I said.

      Google hasn't even deleted any accounts yet, so it is doubly impossible for it to be an example of what @Tikno asked about.

      Google has not allowed blog urls to be reused since early 2016.

      Delete
    3. @Linda
      It could be that is an expired paid domain purchased by someone else or redirected to another page.

      Delete
  4. Let's suppose a blogger schedules annual dummy posts for as far into the future as Google will allow. Would that be sufficient "activity" even if the blogger, say, expires?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ! Really clever idea.

      If so, then to keep this blog online for the next hundred years, just schedule a post for 2123!

      I have no idea if that would work.

      Delete
    2. Just a note that I have successfully scheduled a blog post for September 25, 2523.

      So that part, at any rate, is feasible.

      Whether that will have the desired effect of keeping my account (and this blog) "active" for many centuries after my death, I have no idea!

      And possibly, to effect that result one would have to schedule such a posthumus post every two years, not just once centuries hence.

      Delete
  5. One of my ga, were created in 2015/16 i know full username/password. But i have added 2step verification using phone number. That number is lost. So i can't login. Is there any way to recover?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @MD, I can't say. I have heard from people who have recovered from that situation, and some who have not.

      You should take this question to the Accounts help community.

      Delete
    2. thanks for your reply, as for the main topic, some blog post mentions that if a user have a youtube video uploaded then it will not be subject of account deletion. is this true? if yes, then if i upload a copyright free intro video on youtube from all of my google account . should be done of account inactive problem right?

      Delete
    3. For now, MD, that seems to be true.

      The source for this is Google's announcement, which says, "we do not have plans to delete accounts with YouTube videos at this time" (emphasis added).

      It's not mentioned in the policy.

      So, it might change and is not a sure thing for the long term.

      Note links to both announcement and policy in my blog post above.

      Delete
  6. I did not know this rollout was happening. I went to login in to one of my blogs today and it won't recognize my email address. I tried recovering and I thought that worked but when I go to blogger.com to sign in, it forces me to "create a name for your blog." I've already done that and it still exists if you pull it up by its name, but for some reason I cannot sign into it to make any updates or changes. I've been all over the help forum and there's NOTHING helpful. Do you have any suggestions? Might be helpful to email me at MinxMusic@aol.com in case I can't find your blog again. :-\

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Anonymous. If you are right that your account was deleted as a result of this new policy from Google, and if you are right that you recovered it, then you will have to wait about two days for your blogs to show up.

      I do not know why that is, but it seems to be a quirk whenever a deleted account is restored.

      If you continue to have issues, you should ask about them in the help community. That is the only place I give specific advice, because it is more public than the comments section on my blog!

      Delete
  7. Helle please can you tell me that how can a increase my followers

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey adam,
    I'm new to blogger, can you help me with finding blogs, neither I'm unable to view any of them nor I can find people .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi resfeber, I suggest posting to the Blogger help community (link in sidebar).

      I do have a series of "welcome to Blogger" posts but they do not really address your question.

      Nonetheless, welcome to Blogger!

      Delete